Car insurance is one of those things most of us don’t really think about until life forces us to. You know the drill—you buy a car, you’re told you need insurance, and then you end up comparing endless quotes that all start to blur together. It’s stressful, it’s technical, and frankly, it often feels designed to confuse.
But here’s where 1st for Women comes in with something a little different: car insurance tailored specifically to women. At first glance, that may sound like clever marketing—“pink-washing” with some added perks. I’ll admit, when I first heard about it, I was skeptical. Did women really need their own car insurance? Was it just a branding gimmick, or was there something meaningful behind it?
The more I dug in, though, the more I realised this wasn’t just smoke and mirrors. 1st for Women is built on a pretty straightforward observation: women, on average, tend to be safer drivers than men. Fewer reckless maneuvers, fewer late-night drag races down the highway, and generally fewer claims. Insurance companies know this, but not all of them pass the benefits of that risk profile back to female customers. 1st for Women decided to make it the centerpiece of their offering.
Why “for women” even matters
Now, I know what you might be thinking—should insurance really be split by gender? Isn’t that a bit reductive? Fair question. And the truth is, driving behavior isn’t purely gender-based; plenty of men are safe, responsible drivers, and plenty of women speed or get into accidents. But insurance is a numbers game. It looks at overall trends. And statistically, women do file fewer high-cost claims.
So instead of pretending the numbers don’t exist, 1st for Women leans into them. They offer policies that reflect the lower risk profile, which usually translates into more affordable premiums. And not just that—they throw in extras designed to solve the kinds of problems women are more likely to face on the road.
For instance, think about being stranded late at night with a flat tyre. Yes, technically anyone could find themselves in that situation, but who feels more vulnerable waiting on the side of a quiet road at 10pm? Exactly. This is why their policies often include benefits like roadside and home assistance with a particular awareness of women’s safety concerns.
My own roadside panic
I’ll be honest: I used to think those “added extras” were fluff until I actually needed them. A couple of years back, I had a flat tyre while leaving a friend’s place in Johannesburg. It was late, and the area wasn’t exactly buzzing with people I wanted to run into at night. I knew how to change a tyre (my dad drilled it into me when I first got my license), but there was no way I was going to start fumbling with a jack on a dark street. I ended up calling my roadside assistance, and it felt like the cavalry had arrived. It’s moments like those that make you understand why something like 1st for Women isn’t just about saving a few rand on premiums—it’s about the sense of security woven into the policy.
What sets their policies apart
1st for Women’s car insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all. Like most insurers, they offer the usual tiers—comprehensive, third-party, fire and theft, and third-party only. But the way they frame and support these options is what makes them different.
-
Comprehensive cover: This is the all-in-one safety net. Your own car, other cars, theft, natural disasters—the whole lot. What’s interesting here is that the comprehensive package often comes with those extra safety-driven benefits, like cover for roadside emergencies, trauma counselling, or even home assist services (because life problems rarely stick to “business hours”).
-
Third-party, fire and theft: A budget-conscious option. You’re covered if your car’s stolen or set on fire (hopefully never both in one week), plus you’re protected if you cause damage to someone else’s car.
-
Third-party only: Bare-bones but legal. It’s essentially for those driving older cars where the cost of full cover doesn’t make sense.
Where the difference sneaks in, though, is with the “women-first” perks. Things like a dedicated Guardian Angel service—a call line designed to help women in emergencies. Or automatic roadside and home assistance that feels more holistic than the generic kind. It’s less “tick the box” and more “what would actually help someone if she’s stuck alone?”
The subtle critiques
Of course, it’s not all perfect. One of the things that sometimes nags at me is the assumption that women always need “softer” benefits. There’s a fine line between creating safety-focused insurance and reinforcing stereotypes. Do all women want counselling services, or is that just a neat marketing angle? Not necessarily.
And then there’s the price factor. While 1st for Women often comes in cheaper for female drivers, there are cases where men might be paying more purely for being men—even if their personal driving record is spotless. Some argue that’s unfair. The company’s counterpoint is that they were literally built to balance out the historical bias where women were paying more despite driving better. Still, it’s a debate worth having.
Beyond the car: lifestyle extras
One thing I do appreciate is how 1st for Women stretches the definition of “insurance.” They don’t just stop at covering accidents and repairs. Their policies frequently include add-ons like:
-
Guardian Angel lifestyle assist: Basically, a one-stop helpline for a host of problems, from car breakdowns to a locksmith when you’ve locked yourself out of the house.
-
Legal advice line: Because sometimes you need to know your rights before signing anything or if you’ve been in an accident.
-
Trauma counselling: South Africa isn’t exactly short on stressful driving situations, and having access to counselling after something like a hijacking or accident isn’t just thoughtful—it’s practical.
These extras suggest that 1st for Women sees its role not only as an insurer but also as a kind of “life support system.” Whether that resonates with you may depend on how much you value those peripheral benefits. For me, it’s a nice safety net, even if I hope I never need half of it.
A South African context
It’s worth noting that 1st for Women is uniquely South African. Driving here isn’t the same as driving in Europe or the US. The risks are different. Hijackings, pothole-ridden roads, unreliable traffic lights during load-shedding—all these shape the way insurance has to work here. A brand like 1st for Women appears to understand that. They’re not just cutting-and-pasting global templates; they’re tailoring policies to local realities.
And let’s be real: feeling secure on South African roads is not just about having your bumper fixed after a fender-bender. It’s about knowing you’re not completely on your own when something goes wrong.
Is it right for everyone?
Now here’s the big question: is 1st for Women’s specialized insurance right for every female driver? Not necessarily. If you’re someone who never really uses the extras and prefers the absolute lowest premium available, you might find better deals elsewhere. Some of their benefits, while thoughtful, could feel redundant if you already have similar cover through other providers.
But for a lot of women, especially younger drivers or those who often drive at odd hours, it seems to strike the right balance of affordability, cover, and peace of mind.
Wrapping it all up
When I think back to that night with my flat tyre, I realise insurance isn’t just about the claim you might make one day. It’s about what happens in all the in-between moments—the little emergencies, the “I didn’t think I’d need this until I did” scenarios. That’s where 1st for Women seems to shine.
It’s not perfect—no insurance ever is. There are assumptions baked into their branding, and some of the perks may not be universally appealing. But at the same time, it offers something genuinely useful in a market that too often treats car insurance like a cold spreadsheet calculation.
At its heart, 1st for Women’s specialized car insurance is less about cars and more about people. And for many women in South Africa, that shift in perspective may be exactly what makes it worth considering.