Car insurance isn’t exactly the kind of topic most people get excited about at the dinner table. I mean, when was the last time anyone said, “Wow, I can’t wait to compare excess structures and third-party cover options tonight”? But as a parent or someone managing a household, the reality is that the car sitting in the driveway isn’t just a piece of metal—it’s the thing that gets the kids to school, gets you to work, and takes everyone on that much-needed weekend getaway to the coast. Losing it, or even having it stuck in a panel beater’s workshop for weeks, can throw family life into chaos.
That’s why choosing the right insurer isn’t just about the cheapest premium. It’s about who’s going to have your back when life throws one of its many curveballs. In South Africa, Budget Insurance and 1st for Women are two names that keep popping up, especially for families looking for decent cover without breaking the monthly budget. But the question is: which of the two actually works best for a household juggling multiple needs?
I’ll be honest, I’ve had experience with both insurers—though not directly as the main policyholder. A cousin of mine swears by Budget, while a close friend, who’s a single mom, has been with 1st for Women for years. Their stories, combined with what I’ve dug into, may suggest that the “best” choice isn’t so straightforward. It often depends on what kind of family setup you’ve got, what risks you’re most concerned about, and frankly, what annoys you more: slightly higher premiums or the hassle of hidden costs.
Let’s walk through how these two stack up for families.
The Basics: What Each Offers on Paper
On the surface, Budget Insurance and 1st for Women appear to offer pretty similar comprehensive cover. Both give you the standard lineup: accident cover, theft and hijacking protection, fire damage, third-party liability, hail, floods—the usual suspects. That’s insurance 101.
But the devil, as always, is in the details.
-
Budget Insurance is positioned as the affordable, no-nonsense option. It’s a brand under Telesure (the same group behind Auto & General and Dialdirect), and it aims at people who want decent cover without unnecessary extras. Their hook is affordability.
-
1st for Women, also part of the Telesure group, is marketed more towards female drivers, with extra perks tailored for women—like Guardian Angel on Call (roadside and trauma assistance), lifestyle benefits, and cover extensions that appeal to moms, single women, or families where the primary driver happens to be female.
Now, while families might not care whether the brand has “for Women” in its name, it does mean that 1st for Women builds in services that Budget doesn’t always emphasize. The question is whether those extras are genuinely helpful for households—or just clever marketing.
Premiums: Which One’s Kinder on a Family Budget?
This is usually the dealbreaker. Families have enough monthly expenses, and car insurance tends to slip into that “grudge purchase” category, where you want it, you need it, but you don’t want to overpay.
From what I’ve seen (and confirmed with quotes), Budget Insurance often comes out cheaper for the same type of vehicle. That’s their brand promise. For example, my cousin pays just under R1,000 a month for comprehensive cover on a mid-range SUV, which is impressive considering he’s in Johannesburg—a city that insurers usually penalize heavily because of crime and accident stats.
On the other hand, 1st for Women premiums are typically a little higher, though not outrageously so. Their selling point is that you’re paying for additional built-in benefits, like the trauma and roadside assistance. For a family that values the peace of mind that comes with those extras, the slightly higher premium might not feel like a dealbreaker.
But here’s where it gets tricky: affordability doesn’t just mean “low premium.” Families have to think about excesses—the amount you pay upfront when you claim. Budget may quote you R200 less per month, but if their excess is R5,000 higher, that saving disappears the minute you need to fix a bumper after a parking lot mishap. With kids, parking lot mishaps are not exactly rare.
The Family Factor: Which Serves Households Better?
Let’s look at the family scenarios.
1. Families with Multiple Drivers
If you’ve got teenagers starting to drive, or your partner also uses the car, the policy has to cover multiple people. Both Budget and 1st for Women allow for this, but the difference often lies in the fine print—who’s listed as the regular driver, and whether adding another person bumps up your premium significantly.
Budget seems more straightforward (and cheaper) in this regard. My cousin’s family added his wife as a driver with minimal fuss. Meanwhile, my friend with 1st for Women mentioned her premium shot up when she added her older daughter.
2. Safety Nets Beyond the Car
This is where 1st for Women often shines. Their Guardian Angel service is not just roadside assistance—it’s designed with safety in mind. Picture this: your car breaks down at night, and you’re stuck with the kids in the backseat. A tow truck might come eventually, but having a service that sends out help quickly, with safety as the priority, may feel worth the extra R200 a month.
Budget does have roadside assistance too, but it doesn’t market it with the same family-friendly spin. For households that value that “someone will come to me fast and keep me safe” feeling, 1st for Women’s approach arguably feels more reassuring.
3. Claims Experience
Here’s where families often face the real test. It’s one thing to have glossy ads, but when the car’s at the panel beater, and you’re Ubering kids around for two weeks, you suddenly care about timelines.
Budget Insurance, to be fair, gets mixed reviews. Some people find the claims process quick; others say it drags. My cousin waited three weeks for his car after a rear-end accident—not unusual, but still frustrating.
1st for Women, according to my friend, was much faster when her car was stolen. They handled the paperwork efficiently and even offered trauma counseling—something Budget doesn’t highlight. The counseling may not appeal to everyone, but for her, as someone who was badly shaken by the hijacking, it was invaluable.
Critiques and Limitations
No insurer is perfect, and families need to keep that in mind.
-
Budget Insurance: While cheaper, the trade-off may be in customer service. Complaints about long call center wait times aren’t rare. For busy parents, that’s the last thing you want when you’re already stressed.
-
1st for Women: The biggest critique is that their “women-only” branding can feel limiting or even a little gimmicky. Many dads or couples may feel the extras aren’t necessary or worth the higher premium. Some also argue that other insurers offer similar benefits without the gender-specific spin.
It appears that both brands rely heavily on marketing to create their unique positioning. Budget leans into affordability, while 1st for Women pushes safety and emotional reassurance. Whether those align with your family’s actual needs is the real question.
So, Which Is Best for Families?
If I had to boil it down, I’d say:
-
Choose Budget Insurance if your family’s top priority is saving money each month, and you’re okay with handling the occasional hiccup in customer service. It’s especially appealing for larger households juggling multiple cars or tight budgets.
-
Choose 1st for Women if your family values the built-in extras like trauma support, quicker roadside help, and the added layer of reassurance. It may cost a bit more, but for parents who want to feel safer, that’s money well spent.
And, of course, every family should shop around. What worked for my cousin or my friend won’t necessarily match your circumstances. Insurers calculate premiums on individual factors like your car model, where you live, your driving history, and even where you park at night.
A Personal Take
If I’m honest, if I had to pick today for my own family, I’d probably lean toward 1st for Women—even though I know Budget could save me some cash. Why? Because I’ve seen firsthand how rattled my friend was after her hijacking, and I’d rather have a company that thinks about the emotional side of accidents too. That said, I’d still get a Budget quote—because when school fees, groceries, and petrol are all going up, ignoring the cheaper option feels irresponsible.
At the end of the day, car insurance isn’t glamorous. It’s one of those adult responsibilities we’d rather ignore. But when you’ve got kids relying on you, the stakes feel higher. Whether it’s Budget or 1st for Women, the best choice is the one that keeps your family moving—with as little drama as possible.