Car insurance claims often feel like a mysterious black box. You have an accident, you phone the insurer, and then… what exactly happens behind the scenes? With Santam, one of South Africa’s most established insurance providers, the process is designed to be clear and structured. But anyone who has actually gone through it knows it doesn’t always feel that way in the moment.
I’ll admit—when I first had to submit a car insurance claim with Santam, I was nervous. Not because I didn’t trust them, but because I had no idea what the timeline would look like, what they’d ask me for, or even whether they’d agree with my version of events. I remember sitting in the tow truck after a minor collision on William Nicol Drive in Joburg, scrolling through my phone to figure out what documents I’d need. And like most people, I hoped the process would be smooth but quietly feared it could become a bureaucratic nightmare.
What follows is an attempt to unpack how Santam typically handles car insurance claims—while also reflecting on what’s smooth, what’s frustrating, and what’s worth knowing before you ever have to make the call.
Step One: Reporting the Incident
Everything starts with notifying Santam. That might sound obvious, but the speed with which you report an accident or theft can matter more than you’d expect. Santam generally asks that you report incidents within 30 days, though sooner is always better.
In practice, this means calling their emergency line, using the app, or logging the claim on their website. Personally, I found the phone route less stressful, mainly because you’re speaking to a human who can reassure you that you’re doing things correctly. There’s something oddly comforting about someone on the other end saying, “Okay, don’t worry—we’ve logged the claim, here’s your reference number.”
What they’ll ask for at this stage might catch you off guard: the exact time of the accident, where it happened, details about the other driver, and even whether you’ve reported it to the police. If your car was stolen or hijacked, they’ll insist on a police case number. It’s easy to see why—they need to rule out fraud, which unfortunately isn’t rare in the insurance industry.
That said, some people complain that Santam’s initial questioning feels intense, like being interrogated. One friend of mine who had his car broken into said he felt “treated like a suspect rather than a customer.” It’s a fair criticism, though one could argue that the line between protecting their bottom line and supporting customers is a thin one insurers constantly walk.
Step Two: The Assessment
Once you’ve logged the claim, Santam’s claims team swings into gear. They’ll either assign an assessor or, if the damage is minor, request that you take the vehicle to an approved panel beater for a quote.
In my case, an assessor came to check the damage. He showed up at the tow yard, clipboard in hand, wearing the kind of neutral expression that gives away nothing. I remember wondering if he was already judging whether my car was worth fixing or whether it might be written off.
The assessor’s job is straightforward on paper but layered in practice. They need to determine:
-
How bad the damage is.
-
Whether repairs are possible.
-
What it will cost.
-
And crucially, whether the story you told matches what they see.
For example, if you said you swerved to avoid a dog but the car’s undercarriage looks like it hit a massive pothole, they’ll probably ask questions. Sometimes that feels like skepticism, but from their perspective, it’s due diligence.
This is where frustration can creep in. Santam prides itself on quick turnaround times, but assessments can stretch out, especially if parts of the story don’t line up neatly or if you live in a smaller town with fewer approved workshops. One colleague in Bloemfontein told me she waited almost two weeks just for her car to be assessed because there was only one Santam-approved panel shop in her area.
Step Three: Repair or Write-Off
After the assessment, Santam decides whether your car will be repaired or declared a write-off. This decision isn’t emotional—it’s mathematical. If the cost of repairing the car approaches or exceeds a significant portion of the car’s market value, they’ll write it off.
On one hand, this makes sense. On the other, it can feel devastating. Imagine a car you’ve driven for years, still reliable, still sentimental, suddenly being valued only for scrap because its market value has depreciated on paper. Santam isn’t unique in this approach—it’s how most insurers operate—but it highlights how insurance sometimes collides with our emotional attachment to our possessions.
If they approve repairs, Santam usually directs you to one of their accredited repairers. These shops have contracts with Santam, which often speeds things up because the quotes and paperwork are standardised. The flip side? Customers don’t always get to choose their preferred repairer, and not everyone is thrilled about that. While accredited shops must meet certain standards, some clients feel boxed in, as though their own judgment about where to fix their car doesn’t count.
Step Four: Settlement and Excess
No insurance claim feels real until money enters—or exits—your bank account. With Santam, once the claim is approved, you’re told how much excess you’ll need to pay. Excess is one of those words people nod along to when they buy insurance but sometimes only fully grasp when it hits their wallet.
I learned this the hard way. After my accident, I was told I’d need to pay over R5,000 before repairs could begin. That’s not pocket change, and while I knew about the concept of excess, the actual number still shocked me.
This part of the process can feel harsh, particularly for customers who’ve been loyal to Santam for years without ever claiming. Shouldn’t years of careful driving count for more than a sudden financial penalty? Some might argue yes, though insurers would counter that excess is essential to discourage frivolous claims and share the risk fairly.
For total loss claims (like theft or write-offs), Santam pays out the insured or market value of the car, minus the excess. Payments usually go directly to your bank account, though the timeline can vary—some people report receiving funds within days, others complain of waiting weeks.
Step Five: Getting Back on the Road
The final stage is either collecting your repaired car or using the payout to buy a new one. Santam doesn’t typically offer courtesy cars as part of its standard cover—though you can add this as an optional extra. For anyone who relies heavily on their car, this detail can be a dealbreaker.
I once spent three weeks Ubering to work while waiting for my car to be repaired, and the costs piled up fast. It made me rethink whether adding that optional courtesy car benefit would have been cheaper in the long run. Santam markets its optional extras as “customisation,” but sometimes they feel like essentials dressed up as luxuries.
Customer Experience: Smooth or Stressful?
Theoretically, Santam’s claims process is logical, step-by-step, and professional. And many customers would agree it works well—especially compared to smaller insurers who might lack the infrastructure or network to handle claims efficiently.
But “works well” is not the same as “feels good.” Some policyholders praise Santam’s responsiveness, saying claims were settled faster than expected. Others grumble about feeling left in the dark, having to chase updates, or being frustrated by the formalities.
A pattern seems to emerge: the more complex or unusual the claim, the more likely delays or disputes arise. Straightforward bumper repairs? Usually smooth. Stolen car with sketchy circumstances? Expect probing questions and longer timelines.
A Few Lessons I Took Away
Looking back on my own claim, plus hearing stories from friends and colleagues, I’d boil the Santam claims journey down to a few key lessons:
-
Report quickly, with detail. The sooner you call, the more credible and smoother the process feels.
-
Expect scrutiny. They will ask tough questions—it’s not personal, it’s procedure.
-
Keep your documents handy. Police case number, license, ID—having them upfront can save days of back-and-forth.
-
Budget for excess. It’s easy to forget, but it can sting if you don’t plan for it.
-
Optional extras aren’t always optional. Courtesy car cover, for instance, can make a big difference.
Final Thoughts
Santam processes car insurance claims in a way that is, for the most part, predictable and professional. It’s a system honed by decades of experience, and one that reflects both the strengths and limitations of the South African insurance market.
Does that mean it always feels customer-friendly? Not necessarily. Like most insurers, Santam sits at the awkward intersection of business pragmatism and human expectation. They need to protect themselves against fraud and financial loss, but customers crave empathy and speed.
So, if you ever find yourself on the roadside at night, phoning Santam with your heart racing and your bumper hanging loose, remember: the process will likely unfold step by step, even if it doesn’t always feel comforting in the moment. Knowing how it works won’t prevent the stress, but it may just make the experience a little less intimidating.