If you’ve spent any amount of time in South Africa, you’ll know that bakkies aren’t just vehicles—they’re part of the landscape. Whether it’s a farmer hauling feed across a gravel road, a contractor loading power tools in Johannesburg, or a family hitting the N1 for a long weekend away, the bakkie has carved out its role as both workhorse and adventure buddy. But for all the admiration people have for these vehicles, the topic of insurance—specifically comprehensive cover—often sparks hesitation.
MiWay has positioned itself as one of the go-to insurers for South African drivers, with a special emphasis on those behind the wheel of bakkies. On paper, their comprehensive cover promises peace of mind: protection against accidents, theft, natural disasters, and the unpredictable chaos that comes with daily driving. Yet the question that nags at many bakkie owners is whether MiWay’s offering truly fits their needs—or if it’s simply another insurance product dressed up with flashy marketing.
Let’s unpack that, not in a dry, textbook way, but in the way you’d chat with a mate over a braai while the rugby plays in the background.
Why Bakkies Are Different
When you talk to people about their bakkies, there’s usually a story attached. My uncle, for instance, still drives his twenty-year-old Toyota Hilux, a vehicle that’s seen more of the country than most of us. That bakkie has transported sheep, furniture, surfboards, and once—though no one likes to admit it—a broken fridge that nearly slid off on the R300. Insurance, for him, was always a tick-box exercise. But after his bakkie was dented in a storm that sent a corrugated roof sheet flying, he started asking whether he had been underestimating the importance of proper cover.
And that’s the crux of it. A bakkie isn’t just another car. It often doubles up as business equipment, a family transporter, and a symbol of pride. The risks aren’t the same as a small hatchback weaving through Sandton traffic. Which is why comprehensive insurance may—or may not—make sense depending on how you use it.
What MiWay’s Comprehensive Cover Promises
On the surface, MiWay’s comprehensive plan for bakkies ticks most of the boxes you’d expect. It typically includes:
-
Accident damage cover: Whether you collide with a taxi in rush-hour traffic or misjudge a tight parking space at Builders Warehouse.
-
Theft and hijacking protection: A big concern in South Africa, especially in areas where bakkies are high on the list of stolen vehicles.
-
Natural disaster coverage: Think hailstorms in Gauteng, flooding in KwaZulu-Natal, or veld fires in the Free State.
-
Third-party liability: For those moments where you’re not just worrying about your bakkie but also the car—or person—you might bump into.
-
Optional extras: Things like car hire after an accident or cover for accessories (roof racks, canopies, and even the sound system some people insist on fitting).
It all sounds reassuring, but here’s where some nuance is needed. The reality of comprehensive insurance is that it’s only as valuable as your actual risk profile. For instance, if you live in a rural town with little crime and drive your bakkie once a week, full-blown comprehensive cover may feel like paying for a buffet when you’re only eating a side salad.
The Price vs. Peace-of-Mind Debate
One of the first things bakkie owners grumble about when insurance comes up is cost. MiWay, like most insurers, calculates premiums based on a cocktail of factors: your driving history, where you live, how you use the bakkie, and even whether it sleeps inside a garage or out in the open.
I remember when a friend in Pretoria told me he was paying nearly double for insurance on his Ford Ranger compared to his neighbour’s smaller sedan. “It doesn’t make sense,” he complained. “It’s just a bakkie.” But insurers see it differently. Bakkies are statistically more likely to be stolen, used in high-risk environments, and driven for longer distances. From MiWay’s perspective, that makes them more expensive to insure.
So, is the extra cost worth it? That depends on how much you rely on your bakkie. If it’s your livelihood, the argument leans heavily toward yes. If it’s a secondary vehicle that only comes out on weekends, you might start questioning whether a less comprehensive option—like third-party, fire, and theft—could be enough.
Real-World Scenarios That Test Coverage
The marketing brochures always highlight accidents and theft, but the real test comes with the less predictable scenarios.
Imagine this: you’re towing a trailer full of garden supplies and a sudden storm turns the road into a muddy slip-and-slide. The bakkie skids, the trailer jackknifes, and you end up with more than a few dents. Would MiWay cover that? From what I’ve gathered, yes, but only if the trailer is insured as well. If not, you may find yourself out of pocket for part of the mess.
Or take another example: someone adds a custom canopy with tool storage to their Nissan Navara. Those extras might feel like part of the vehicle, but unless they’re declared and covered, an insurance payout after theft could exclude them. That’s one area where many drivers, not just with MiWay but with insurers in general, get caught off guard.
The Psychological Side of Insurance
There’s also a mental element we don’t talk about often enough. Owning a bakkie without comprehensive cover can create a nagging anxiety. Every time you leave it parked outside a shopping centre, there’s that little voice asking: “What if?” Insurance—particularly the more complete kind—quietens that voice. For some people, that psychological comfort alone justifies the monthly debit order.
On the flip side, there are those who feel resentful, believing they’re throwing money into a black hole, especially if they never claim. MiWay’s “cash back bonus” (a perk where you get money back after a few claim-free years) is clearly designed to soften that resentment. Does it work? For some, yes—it feels like a reward for cautious driving. For others, the payback is too small to shift the bigger picture.
Customer Service and Claims Experience
Insurance isn’t just about the policy wording—it’s also about how the insurer handles things when disaster strikes. MiWay has built a reputation for being fairly accessible, with online policy management and a no-fuss claims process. That said, reviews are mixed, as they usually are in this industry. Some customers rave about quick payouts, while others complain about delays or unexpected exclusions.
This is where a subtle critique emerges. Comprehensive cover may sound complete, but exclusions and fine print matter. For instance, was your bakkie being used for business deliveries? Was the driver at the time not listed on the policy? Those technicalities can derail claims, leaving drivers frustrated.
Alternative Perspectives
It’s tempting to frame comprehensive cover as the gold standard, but let’s pause and consider other options. For some owners, particularly those with older bakkies that no longer hold high market value, comprehensive cover might not be cost-effective. Paying thousands in premiums every year for a vehicle worth R60,000 doesn’t always add up. In those cases, a stripped-down policy could make more financial sense.
There’s also the argument that investing in preventative measures—tracking devices, secure parking, and careful driving habits—may provide as much peace of mind as an expensive policy. Insurance, after all, is about balancing cost against risk, and that balance isn’t identical for everyone.
A Personal Reflection
When I think back to my own experience insuring a bakkie, I can still remember the moment it all felt worth it. I had just finished a weekend away in Mpumalanga. On the drive back, a kudu darted across the road. I slammed the brakes, but not before the bakkie clipped its hind leg and the bonnet crumpled like a tin can. Shaken, I phoned my insurer—MiWay, in this case—and within days the repairs were sorted. The relief of not having to scrape together tens of thousands of rands was immense.
Would I have felt differently if I had never claimed? Probably. It might have felt like wasted money. But that’s the unpredictable nature of life on South African roads—you never know when the kudu will jump.
Final Thoughts
MiWay’s comprehensive cover for bakkies offers a wide safety net that seems well suited to South African conditions. It appears to protect against the big fears—accidents, theft, disasters—while offering add-ons for the smaller, often overlooked details. But like any insurance product, its value isn’t universal. For some, it’s an essential safeguard. For others, especially those driving older bakkies or living in lower-risk environments, it may feel excessive.
The real takeaway is this: don’t buy comprehensive cover simply because it’s the default choice. Think about how you use your bakkie, what risks you face daily, and how much financial shock you could realistically handle on your own. If your livelihood, family safety, or sanity relies on your bakkie, then MiWay’s comprehensive option is probably worth serious consideration. If not, the buffet might be more than you need.
Insurance, like driving itself, is all about navigating uncertainty. The road is unpredictable, but with the right cover—whether comprehensive or something lighter—you can at least choose how much of that unpredictability you’re willing to shoulder alone.
Continue reading – Old Mutual’s Guide to Matching Insurance to Your Car’s Value